Main argument
What it tests: separating the writer's conclusion from the findings that lead up to it.
Real passage: adapted and shortened from George Sanglier's petitions: two sides to every petition, Briony Paxman, The National Archives blog, 2015 (Open Government Licence v3.0).
One case which recently piqued my interest was that of George Sanglier, the master of Lambeth Workhouse. Sanglier was convicted at the Central Criminal Court in November 1838 and sentenced to seven years’ transportation for embezzling money, the property of the guardians of the Lambeth Poor Law Union. … Here was an opportunity to find out how Sanglier’s side of the story in his petitions compared with what his prosecutors, the Guardians at Lambeth, reported to their superiors. … Correspondence in the Poor Law Commission archive in MH 12 certainly confirms George’s claims of a rift with his employers at Lambeth. … Pressed for evidence by the Commission they report ‘ocular evidence’ of his drunkenness on several occasions and that Sanglier had appeared at a meeting ‘in a state of intoxication’.
Comparing Sanglier’s petitions in HO 17 and related Poor Law correspondence in MH 12 has been a thought-provoking exercise. I set out hoping to find a balance to Sanglier’s rather inevitable claims of innocence in his petitions. … When working with the petitions we are aware that their authors will (by and large) try to paint a convict in the best possible light, so perhaps it is inevitable that even when the surviving government archive provides us with more information about the crime and the convict’s previous life, questions remain as to what really happened and whose version of events is most reliable.
What is the writer's main argument in the passage?
Reveal the answer and explanation
Correct answer: A
Why A is right: the last paragraph draws the conclusion. The writer hoped the archive would balance Sanglier's petitions, and found that even with more information “questions remain as to what really happened and whose version of events is most reliable”.
B is wrong because it is a premise that supports the conclusion. The writer uses petitions painting convicts “in the best possible light” to explain why questions remain.
C is wrong because it is one finding along the way. The archive “certainly confirms” the rift, but the writer goes on to say the full story is still uncertain.
D is wrong because the writer never settles what really happened. The Guardians report drunkenness, and Sanglier was convicted of embezzlement, a different matter.